Is the Recorder the Elementary Music Classroom's MVP or Just a Squeaky Sideline Star?

Ah, the sweet, sweet sound of the recorder - a staple in many elementary music classrooms. Indeed, the recorder is an excellent instrument for young learners as it lays a solid foundation for understanding musical concepts. Its simple design and the ability to change notes by merely covering holes make it an easy and accessible instrument for kids to play.

However, as much as we all adore recorders, there are other alternatives worth considering in the magical world of elementary music education. Instruments such as the xylophone, hand percussion, and ukulele provide different learning experiences and can be just as enjoyable for young students. Each instrument offers unique benefits, helping to foster a love for music while teaching valuable skills!

So, while the recorder remains an age-old classic in elementary music classrooms, remember that it happily shares the stage with other wonderful instruments waiting to be discovered by budding musicians. Variety is the spice of life, and music class is no exception!

The Recorder: A Classic Classroom Hit

Undoubtedly, the recorder has earned its place in the elementary music classroom. This popular wind instrument is relatively easy to learn and play, making it a fantastic introduction to music for young students. Its flute-like sound and versatility in teaching basic music concepts have made it a classroom staple.

However, there are other viable music instrument alternatives. Here are a few options:

• Ukulele: An excellent choice for teaching students a string instrument. Learning how to read & perform chords and individual notes through standard music notations and even tablature. It's easier and more affordable than a guitar and is the perfect size for an elementary student. 

• Hand Drums: Percussion instruments like hand drums can help students understand rhythm and provide a hands-on, engaging experience.

• Boomwhackers: These colorful, tuned plastic tubes are a fun way for students to explore pitch, melody, and harmony while working together in a group setting.

• Keyboard: Keyboards can advance students' understanding of pitch, harmony, and even composition, as they can play multiple notes simultaneously.

While the recorder remains a tried-and-tested instrument for music education, it's worth considering these alternatives, which can bring variety and new challenges to the classroom. Each instrument offers unique learning opportunities for students and can complement or supplement recorder lessons to foster a comprehensive music education.

Ultimate Free Recorder Resource

Grab a fun FREE recorder lesson with high-quality videos, slide presentations & printables to get your recorder program started in the right direction!

The Kazoo: Unleashing Your Inner Bee

While the recorder is a popular choice for teaching music in an elementary classroom, there are other options that can make learning music just as enjoyable. One such alternative is the humble kazoo.

The kazoo has a unique quality: instead of requiring a student to blow air to create sound, the instrument relies on humming to produce vibrations. This distinct feature makes the kazoo a great option for getting elementary students to work on their singing & pitch skills. Some benefits of using kazoos in the classroom may include:

• Aural skills development

• Encouraging creativity

• Easing the cognitive demands of learning a new instrument

• Singing! Ever have a student who just doesn't;t want to sing? The Kazoo can help! 

All in all, while the recorder remains a classic choice for elementary music education, it's worth considering alternatives like the kazoo to maintain students' interest and unleash their musical potentials in a fun and engaging way.

The Ukulele: Say Aloha to Music

While the recorder is a fantastic instrument for introducing music to elementary students, it's also worth considering the ukulele as an alternative. Characterized by its small size and cheerful sound, the ukulele has gained popularity as a versatile and approachable instrument in the classroom.

One of the main advantages of the ukulele is its simplicity. With only four strings compared to a guitar's six, forming chords and learning to play is easier for beginners, particularly for young students with smaller hands. 

Moreover, the ukulele offers several educational benefits. When students learn to tune the instrument, they improve their pitch and relative pitch perception, which in turn enhances their singing skills. Additionally, playing the ukulele fosters hand-eye coordination, fine and gross motor skills, and kinesthetic movement.
 

Ukuleles come in a variety of sizes, with the soprano ukulele being the most popular choice for elementary music classrooms due to its affordable price and appropriateness for children's hands.

The Kala- KA 15S Soprano Ukulele is a fantastic choice for your elementary music classroom. Great sound, is durable & stays in tune. 

In conclusion, the ukulele offers a pleasant and engaging alternative to the recorder for elementary music education. By incorporating the ukulele into your lesson plans, you may discover new opportunities for creativity, enjoyment, and skill development for your students.

Boomwhackers: Colorful Fun Sticks

While the recorder is a great instrument for the elementary music classroom, it's not the only option. Introducing Boomwhackers! These colorful, fun sticks are fantastic alternatives to the traditional recorder for getting students engaged in the world of music.

Boomwhackers are tuned plastic tubes that produce different musical pitches when struck against surfaces or each other. They come in various sizes and colors, making them visually appealing to young learners. Easy to play and handle, they promote cooperation and teamwork as students work together to create harmonious tunes.

Beyond their simplicity and visual appeal, Boomwhackers offer numerous benefits for the music classroom. Here are a few:

• They accommodate various skill levels, allowing both beginners and more advanced players to participate.

• Boomwhackers encourage creativity, as students can experiment with different striking methods and rhythms.

• They can be easily incorporated into a range of activities and lesson plans, fostering a fun and engaging learning environment.

With Boomwhackers, the possibilities for musical exploration are endless. Give these colorful fun sticks a try in your elementary classroom, and watch as your students discover the joy of creating music with the Boomin' with Bach Play Along! Your students will not only get to play a variety of pieces by Bach on the boomwhackers, but learn fun facts about the great composer, Johann Sebastion Bach!  

The Chime Choir: Ding Dong, Music's Calling

While the recorder is an excellent choice for young music students, let's not forget about the beautiful sounds of the chime choir. A chime choir, ensemble, or team performs music on a set of handheld chimes tuned to the chromatic scale. This exciting alternative offers several unique benefits to students.

For one, chime choirs encourage teamwork and collaboration, as each musician is responsible for only one or a few select notes. When played together, these notes create rich melodies and harmonies. Students learn to rely on one another, to listen carefully to their fellow musicians, and to develop a strong sense of timing.

Furthermore, chimes accommodate a range of ability levels, making them an inclusive option for students of all backgrounds. No prior musical training is necessary, allowing children to focus on rhythm, tone, and basic music reading skills.

The Suzuki Chimes offer two octaves (G4-G6) and additionally, you can add lower & higher chimes to create three full octaves.

Additionally, boomwhacker play-alongs can be used when playing the chimes! A perfect play-along that has students learning about classical composers is Classical Boomwhackers.

In a nutshell, the chime choir is a fantastic alternative to the recorder that promotes teamwork, inclusivity, and musical exploration. Next time you're planning your elementary music classroom activities, consider going beyond recorders and give chimes a try!

Conclusion: Embrace the World of Tiny Instruments

While the recorder has proven to be an easy-to-play and accessible instrument for elementary music classrooms, there are other alternatives that can also work wonders in teaching our bright little musicians.

All in all, while the recorder has been a staple of elementary music education for decades, branching out and exploring other engaging instruments will empower our little virtuosos and create a rich experience in their music learning journey.

Ultimate Free Recorder Resource

Grab a fun FREE recorder lesson with high-quality videos, slide presentations & printables to get your recorder program started in the right direction!